Peanut Butter Products

36 items found
5% Nutrition Snack Time Peanut Butter - 10 Pouches
5% Nutrition Snack Time Peanut Butter - 10 Pouches
#5P107In stock
$24.78
30% Off Special Offer
Fit Butters Banana Maple French Toast (Vegan) Cashew/Almond Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Banana Maple French Toast (Vegan) Cashew/Almond Butter - 1 Lb
#FB007In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Birthday Cake Cashew/Almond Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Birthday Cake Cashew/Almond Butter - 1 Lb
#FB013In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Brookie Cashew Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Brookie Cashew Butter - 1 Lb
#FB033In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Caramel Apple Peanut Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Caramel Apple Peanut Butter - 1 Lb
#FB025
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Caramel Fudge Coconut Cookie Cashew/Almond Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Caramel Fudge Coconut Cookie Cashew/Almond Butter - 1 Lb
#FB015In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Chocolate Caramel Crunch Bar Cashew Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Chocolate Caramel Crunch Bar Cashew Butter - 1 Lb
#FB030In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cashew Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cashew Butter - 1 Lb
#FB009In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Chocolate Dirt Cake Cashew Peanut Blend - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Chocolate Dirt Cake Cashew Peanut Blend - 1 Lb
#FB020In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cashew Almond Blend - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cashew Almond Blend - 1 Lb
#FB031In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Chocolate Peanut Butter Wafer Peanut Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Chocolate Peanut Butter Wafer Peanut Butter - 1 Lb
#FB035In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Cinnamon Sugar Cookie (Vegan) Cashew/Almond Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Cinnamon Sugar Cookie (Vegan) Cashew/Almond Butter - 1 Lb
#FB014In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Cocoa PEBBLES Cashew Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Cocoa PEBBLES Cashew Butter - 1 Lb
#FB028In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Cookie Butter Cashew Almond Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Cookie Butter Cashew Almond Butter - 1 Lb
#FB029In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Fruity PEBBLES Cashew Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Fruity PEBBLES Cashew Butter - 1 Lb
#FB027In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Golden Cream Cookie Cashew Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Golden Cream Cookie Cashew Butter - 1 Lb
#FB032In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Monster Cookie Peanut Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Monster Cookie Peanut Butter - 1 Lb
#FB005In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Rory’s Cookie Monster Madness (Cookies & Cream Cashew Butter) - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Rory’s Cookie Monster Madness (Cookies & Cream Cashew Butter) - 1 Lb
#FB008In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Salted Caramel Pretzel Peanut Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Salted Caramel Pretzel Peanut Butter - 1 Lb
#FB012In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters Scotcheroo Peanut Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters Scotcheroo Peanut Butter - 1 Lb
#FB017In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Fit Butters White Chocolate Macadamia Peanut Butter - 1 Lb
Fit Butters White Chocolate Macadamia Peanut Butter - 1 Lb
#FB034In stock
$13.99
Quantity discounts available!
Buy 2 or more $12.99 each
Nuts n More Almond Butter - 15 Oz
Nuts n More Almond Butter - 15 Oz
#NM003In stock
$14.98
20% Off Special Offer
Nuts n More Birthday Cake - 15 Oz
Nuts n More Birthday Cake - 15 Oz
#NM016In stock
$12.95
20% Off Special Offer
Nuts n More Butter Cup! High Protein Peanut Butter Spread - 15 Oz
Nuts n More Butter Cup! High Protein Peanut Butter Spread - 15 Oz
#NM035In stock
$12.95
20% Off Special Offer
Nuts n More Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough - 15 oz
Nuts n More Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough - 15 oz
#NM021In stock
$12.95
20% Off Special Offer
Nuts n More Chocolate Maple Pretzel - 15 Oz
Nuts n More Chocolate Maple Pretzel - 15 Oz
#NM015In stock
$12.95
20% Off Special Offer
Nuts n More Cookies n Cream High Protein Peanut Butter Spread - 15 Oz
Nuts n More Cookies n Cream High Protein Peanut Butter Spread - 15 Oz
#NM036In stock
$12.95
20% Off Special Offer
Nuts n More Dark Chocolate Almond Butter - 15 Oz
Nuts n More Dark Chocolate Almond Butter - 15 Oz
#NM034
$14.98
20% Off Special Offer
Nuts n More Peanut Spread - 15 Oz
Nuts n More Peanut Spread - 15 Oz
#NM002In stock
$12.95
20% Off Special Offer
Nuts n More Salted Caramel - 15 Oz
Nuts n More Salted Caramel - 15 Oz
#NM013In stock
$12.95
20% Off Special Offer
Nuts n More Toffee Crunch - 16 Oz
Nuts n More Toffee Crunch - 16 Oz
#NM004In stock
$12.95
20% Off Special Offer
Nuts n More White Chocolate Pretzel - 15 Oz
Nuts n More White Chocolate Pretzel - 15 Oz
#NM032In stock
$12.95
20% Off Special Offer
Nuts n More Wild Honey - 15 Oz
Nuts n More Wild Honey - 15 Oz
#NM033In stock
$12.95
20% Off Special Offer
Professor Nutz Peanut Butter - 12 Oz
Professor Nutz Peanut Butter - 12 Oz
#PAD14
$15.99
20% Off Special Offer
Professor Nutz Peanut Butter Caramel Kiss - 12 Oz
Professor Nutz Peanut Butter Caramel Kiss - 12 Oz
#PAD63In stock
$15.99
20% Off Special Offer
Professor Nutz Peanut Butter Chocolate - 12 Oz
Professor Nutz Peanut Butter Chocolate - 12 Oz
#PAD15
$15.99
20% Off Special Offer

Peanut butter lovers will find a treasure trove of flavors and textures that cater to every taste preference. From rich chocolate blends to unique cookie-inspired variations, the selection is extensive. Brands like Fit Butters and Nuts n More redefine traditional peanut butter with exciting new options, ensuring there's something for everyone.

Each product in this collection is crafted to deliver not just on taste but also on quality. Whether looking for a quick snack or an ingredient to elevate your recipes, these peanut butter options offer versatility and nutritional benefits. Savor the convenience of grab-and-go pouches or opt for indulgent flavors that keep cravings at bay while contributing valuable protein and healthy fats to your diet.